LordBullingdon [none/use name]

  • 6 Posts
  • 78 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: September 9th, 2023

help-circle





  • The correlation I see with Rome (and which could be applied to so many other empires) is that people, and in particular the elite gave up on the project of state. This was the case both when the republic shifted to empire and also when the western empire collapsed. ‘Rome’ at this time was just the status quo that let the elite ransack wealth, it didn’t mean anything beyond that, there was no more willingness to sacrifice to or even value the ideal it represented. So in the US nowdays with neoliberalism the same sort of process is taking place. Instead of ghouls that are nonetheless statesmen who basically want to preserve and strengthen America you have failsons and madmen but also intelligent people who nonetheless recognise the way the wind is blowing and that now is the time to fill your pockets rather than dream big. And of course the working class is also losing faith in the national ideal too, and when the Goths ransacked Rome it was because there was no-one left to defend it because everyday Romans just refused to serve in the military. And they refused to serve because there was no point, and when Rome collapsed, initially at least life actually improved for a lot of the working class and it didn’t even change that much for a lot of the elites either, other than they had to call the barbarians boss instead of the emperor.








  • Yes that’s a great point.
    It’s also the case in for example the Uk and Australia (not sure about US) that the trade unions are largely captive to the social-democratic Labour Party, which is itself captured by neoliberal ideologues.
    And then you have some other more progressive parties that don’t really have trade Union support and are mostly made up of people that are I suppose ‘cultural’ elites (highly educated, urban, etc), and are regarded by many working class people as fantasists who would damage them via environmentalism and pro-immigration policies (or whatever other culture war boogeyman the media happens to be pushing) Having said that we have seen repeatedly (Corbyn, Sanders, and I suppose technically even Obama) how effectively grass roots campaigning can overcome the media/bourgeois stranglehold when it’s done competently. You only need a relatively small core of people who are enthusiastic enough to campaign, to talk to their friends and family, and the status quo is revealed for the paper tiger it is. Because everyone already has the foundational idea that the MSM isn’t to be trusted.
    But the right is exploiting this better than we are.
    And when these grass roots organisations are set up by party machine politicians like Sanders or Corbyn, they fall apart as soon as the immediate aim of supporting the politician into power is no longer relevant




  • I think in a rational society if someone wanted to do something harmful to themselves - whether it’s fast to death, or use drugs, or whatever - then it could just be treated like we treat so many other dangerous activities. If you want to drive a car you have to take a test to prove that your competent. So I suppose if someone wanted to fast to death they could have an assessment by a psychologist or some kind of expert, to ensure they haven’t been brainwashed or groomed or whatever and understand what they are doing, and if they do, then let them do it. But if it’s some kid that has been raised by cultists that would be flagged and their application to starve to death would be denied